Fallon O'Neil is a scarred former actress trying to rebuild her confidence when she meets Ben Kessler, an aspiring novelist, on November 9th—the exact anniversary of the devastating fire that ruined her career. The two experience an immediate, life-altering connection, deciding to meet on the exact same date every single year for five years, completely forbidding any digital contact in between. Ben uses Fallon as the central muse for his manuscript, and their yearly reunions match their evolving personal growth. However, a shocking twist in the manuscript's pages reveals a horrifying truth about the night of the fire, turning their unique romantic tradition into a devastating psychological battlefield.